James Uthmeier’s formal opinion finds the 2018 law, which reaches forced reset triggers as well as bump stocks, violates the Second Amendment.
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier announced Friday that his office will no longer defend convictions under the state’s 2018 ban on rate-of-fire devices, a law that sweeps in forced reset triggers along with bump stocks. His formal legal opinion concludes the law violates the Second Amendment.
In a post on X, Uthmeier said the “overly broad law appears to restrict the use of trigger enhancements” used by gun owners for lawful purposes, and noted that it subjects violators “to five years in prison.”
The opinion goes beyond a narrow reading of the statute. It names forced reset triggers among the components the law reaches, and describes the ban as one that “imposes a categorical prohibition on an entire class of firearm components” that can increase a semiautomatic firearm’s rate of fire.
Semiautomatic firearms with those modifications “are bearable arms covered by the Second Amendment’s plain text,” the opinion states.
That language tracks the framework the U.S. Supreme Court set out in its 2022 Bruen decision. Under Bruen, when the Second Amendment’s plain text covers an individual’s conduct, the government must show a restriction is consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.
The ban was part of the gun control package Florida lawmakers passed weeks after the February 14, 2018, shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland. Signed by then-Gov. Rick Scott, the law also raised the minimum age to buy a rifle from 18 to 21, created the state’s “red flag” law, funded school safety measures and created a “guardian” program for armed school personnel.
The U.S. Supreme Court struck down the federal bump stock ban in 2024 in a 6-3 decision, ruling that a bump stock does not convert a semiautomatic rifle into a machine gun because the trigger must still be released and reengaged for each shot. Florida’s state ban was unaffected by that ruling. Federally, forced reset triggers have been legal to sell since May 2025, when the Justice Department settled a lawsuit brought by the National Association for Gun Rights over the ATF’s attempt to classify them as machine guns.
The opinion does not repeal the law. The statute stays on the books until the Legislature changes it or a court strikes it down. But the Attorney General’s Office represents the state in criminal appeals, meaning convictions challenged on appeal will no longer have the state’s top lawyer defending them.
It is not the first time Uthmeier has broken with the 2018 law. In August 2025, he said his office would not defend the law’s ban on long gun purchases by adults under 21.
The 2018 law has faced growing criticism from Florida Republicans. Governor-elect Byron Donalds, who voted against the bill as a state House member, has criticized its gun control provisions.
Read more at Breitbart.
